Brand Comparison

Silicone Freezer Tray Face-Off: Rigid Lid vs Flexible Lid — Which Seal Style Works Better for Families?

Two steel-reinforced silicone freezer trays, two very different lid approaches. We break down which seal style keeps family meals fresher and which one fits your freezer habits better.

25 Aug 2026 Editorial Team 3 min read

Why Lid Design Matters More Than You Think

When you're freezing soups, sauces, and baby food in bulk, the lid is what stands between a neatly organized freezer and a sticky, cross-contaminated mess. Two popular silicone freezer tray sets — one from CyhHave, one from Doasuwish — both use stainless steel reinforcement and BPA-free platinum silicone. But they take opposite approaches to sealing. Here's how those differences play out in a real family kitchen.

Meet the Contenders

Silicone Freezer Trays with Lids, 2 Cup & 1 Cup & 1/2 Cup Soup Freezer Container Molds for Freezer - Leakproof, Dishwasher, Oven Safe, Ideal for Frozen Broth, Leftovers & Meal Prep, BPA Free 3 Pack by CyhHave uses a transparent, rigid-style lid that clamps onto each compartment individually. You can see what's inside without popping the top — handy when you've frozen several batches and need to grab chicken broth, not pumpkin puree.

3-Pack Silicone Freezer Trays with Lid,2 Large 2-Cup(500ml)&4 Medium 1-Cup(250ml)&6 Small 1/2-Cup(125ml) Soup Freezer Container Molds,Ice Cube Tray For Meal Prep&Freezing Soup,Stews,Sauces by Doasuwish opts for a flexible silicone lid. It also seals each compartment individually but adds an explicit odor-resistant barrier that prevents flavor transfer between portions — a real advantage when you store garlicky stew next to sweet fruit puree.

Rigid Lid vs Flexible Lid: The Key Differences

Feature	CyhHave (Transparent Lid)	Doasuwish (Flexible Lid)
Lid material	Transparent rigid	Flexible silicone
Content visibility	Yes — see through lid	No — must open to check
Odor/flavor barrier	Sealed compartments	Sealed + odor-resistant
Compartment count	3 (one per tray)	12 across 3 trays
Size variety	½ cup, 1 cup, 2 cup	½ cup, 1 cup, 2 cup + ¼ cup marks
Rating	4.6/5	4.8/5
Value tier	Budget-friendly	Mid-range

When the Transparent Lid Wins

CyhHave's see-through top saves time when you're scanning the freezer for a specific portion. If you freeze the same type of food often — say, a big batch of broth divided into three sizes — visibility matters less, but for households that freeze several different recipes, peeking without unsealing is genuinely useful. The budget-friendly pricing also makes this set an easy entry point.

Check latest price — CyhHave

When the Flexible Lid Wins

Doasuwish's silicone lid won't crack or warp over time the way rigid plastic can. The odor-resistant seal between compartments is the standout feature: frozen strawberry smoothie cubes sitting next to onion soup won't pick up off-flavors. You also get 12 individual compartments across the three trays and ¼-cup measurement marks, giving you finer portion control — especially useful for baby food or small-batch sauces.

Check latest price — Doasuwish

Verdict

Both trays deliver on the essentials: steel-reinforced frames that resist sagging, leak-proof compartment seals, dishwasher and oven safety, and BPA-free platinum silicone. The real decision comes down to how you use your freezer.

Who it suits

Choose CyhHave if you freeze multiple recipe types and want to identify contents at a glance, or if you prefer a simpler, budget-friendly 3-compartment setup.
Choose Doasuwish if odor crossover is a dealbreaker, you need more compartments per batch, or you want the durability of a flexible lid that won't crack over time.

Who should skip

Skip CyhHave if you need to store strongly scented foods side by side — the transparent lid seals well but doesn't specifically block odor transfer between compartments.
Skip Doasuwish if you only freeze one or two items at a time and don't need 12 compartments or ¼-cup precision — the extra capacity may go unused.

Both are solid upgrades from plastic containers and disposable bags. Pick the lid style that matches how your family actually uses the freezer.